As a background pic? Definitely the Alice one.
"Thieves" is a kick ass track, BTW.
I liked the Alice one. Tres cool
as far as desktop pics go, i prefer the one i'm currently using...
i call her "rootbeer float".
also, i don't really see the point/objective of comparing an original graphic that was created to be used in tandem with smilies to a desktop picture that was created to advertise a videogame.